There is a fibrous muscle on the side of the scallop that needs to be removed. It’s really easy to spot and you just pull it right off. Part of the reason I never cooked scallops was because I was worried about this step. I was totally freaked out about it for some reason. Trust me, after doing it once, I feel like an idiot because it’s that easy. It peels off like a sticker.
Rinse the scallop in cold water and pat dry with paper towels. I let mine sit for a few minutes and then pat them again. You want them to be totally dry.
Generously top scallops with salt and pepper on both sides.
In a pan, heat up the butter and oil over high heat. Once you see a little smoke, your oil/butter is ready. This happens fast so watch it! The second you see smoke, you need to get them in the pan.
Using tongs, arrange the scallops in the pan and once you place them down, DO NOT TOUCH THEM! This is how you get your perfect seared scallops. After a minute and a half, take your tongs and flip them (in the same order you put them down). Again, don’t touch them.
Wait another minute and a half and remove from pan with tongs.